At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked overnight babysitters in New York, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Available Now in New York
Jessica B. says "Paige was our nanny for a year, starting when our daughter was 4. We were first-time parents and she taught us so much in addition to caring deeply for...
Todd C. says "Eden is pretty much perfect in every way. She's like the contemporary Marry Poppins. She is smart, kind, gentle, responsible, fun, dependable, and is truly...
Jared R. says "We had Kaalyah babysit our 22 month old son, after she came highly recommended from another family. Our son enjoyed playing with Kaalyah right away and...
Sarah S. says "Awesome young lady. Pleasure to meet her."
Care Member says "Moriah helped care for my three children (ages 6, 1.5y, newborn). Moriah is extremely capable of caring for multiple children with an emphasis on...
Edwin F. says "Taryn is a charming and magnificent person. She's not only friendly, but smart and talented. Definitely the best!"
Rachel B. says "We loved working with Elisa. She immediately connected with our son and clearly loved interacting with him. She was amazing during both the infant and...
Showing 561 - 580 of 643
643 overnight babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $22.49/hr as of October 2025
The average star rating for rated overnight babysitters is 4.8
Overnight Babysitters in New York, NY are rated 4.8 out of 5 stars based on 289 reviews of the 642 listed overnight babysitters
- Jessica B.
- Todd C.
- Jared R.
Not sure how to find a babysitter near you in New York, NY that you can trust to watch your children overnight? You can use Care.com to search for overnight babysitters who can tackle the babysitter duties you need help with and who have an overnight babysitting rate that aligns with your budget. You can search by years of experience and read through reviews from families to get an idea of how trustworthy an overnight babysitter is, but it’s always a good idea to do your own interview and check their references.
Overnight babysitters in New York, NY start at $22.49, but the exact cost of hiring a babysitter to stay overnight can vary based on each sitter’s years of experience and qualifications.
Overnight babysitters can take on a wide variety of babysitter duties. You can search Care.com profiles to find an overnight sitter who can help with tasks like cooking, laundry, light housekeeping, and homework. Review 642 profiles to see which babysitter duties care providers near New York, NY feel comfortable tackling.